Notes
Slide Show
Outline
1
Challenging Times for Making Refinery Capacity Decisions
  • Joanne Shore
  • John Hackworth
  • Energy Information Administration
  • NPRA Annual Meeting
  • March 2004
2
Capacity Surplus Disappearing, Creating Short-Term Challenge
3
But Long Term, Will We Need Petroleum Capacity?
4
Uncertain Factors Affect Capacity Decisions, But Can Learn From History
5
Demand – A Crucial Factor Affecting Capacity Decisions
  • Future growth forecasts


  • What could affect future growth?


6
Transportation Demand Growth Drives EIA’s Reference Case
7
Efficiency Could Affect Demand,
But How Quickly?
8
Historical Efficiencies Affected Demand Relatively Quickly
9
Gasoline Imports – A Competitive and Essential Supply Source
10
Changing U.S. Specifications May Change Import Sources
11
Some Historical Suppliers Cannot Produce Low Sulfur Gasoline
12
EU-15 Demand Mix May Imply Excess European Mogas Supply
13
European New Vehicle Choices Show Why Diesel Fuel Growth May Continue
14
EU Hydrocracking Growing, But Not as Fast as Mogas/Diesel Demand Shift
15
Imports – Less Competitive in the Short Term
  • Short-term:
    • Fuel spec changes may be reducing number of potential import sources
    • Reduction in import sources may increase margins
    • But will that change over time?
  • Long-term:
    • May still see higher product imports
    • Can capacity investment today compete tomorrow?
16
Historical Capacity Change May Provide Insights into Future Change
  • Historical growth
  • Closures
  • Operating Refinery Profile
  • Yield Improvements



17
Total Capacity Grew Since Mid 1990’s
18
Closures Still Occurring, But Rate Slowing
19
Capacity Growth Largest for Mid-Sized Refineries
20
Distillation Capacity Grew with Conversion Capacity
21
Transportation Fuel Production Increased through Yield Improvements
22
Future Volume Increases May Not Benefit from Yield* Improvements
  • Yield Decline Factors
  • MTBE bans
  • Focus on stream treating vs. conversion
  • Achieving ultra-low sulfur specifications
  • Other specification requirements (cetane, aromatics, driveability)
  • Reliability deterioration with increasing complexity
  • Refinery feed quality deterioration
  • Yield Improvement Factors
  • More hydrocracking
  • More refinery upgrading projects
  • No oxygen mandate


23
Risk:  Will Return on Investment Be Realized?
24
Closing Points
  • Environment may be improving for U.S. capacity expansion
    • U.S. needs increasing petroleum fuel volumes for some time
    • Product import sources decline in short term – but long term?
    • Specification changes reducing refinery capability
    • Consequences – Continued higher margins
  • Yet keep an eye on the long term; large changes can occur