The National Energy Modeling System: An Overview 2003

Characteristics of Selected Space Heating Equipment in the Commercial Sector

   Equipment Type1

Vintage

Efficiency2

Capital Cost (2001 dollars per
thousand Btu
per hour)3

Maintenance Cost
(2001 dollars
per
thousand Btu
per hour)3

Service Life
(years)

  Electric Heat Pump    

Current Standard

6.8

$81.39

$3.33

14

 

2000- typical    

7.5

$97.92

$3.33

14

 

2000- high efficiency

9.8

$155.56

$3.33

14

 

2005- typical     

7.5

$97.22

$3.33

14

 

2005- high efficiency

9.8

$155.56

$3.33

14

 

2010 - typical    

7.5

$97.22

$3.33

14

 

2010 - high efficiency

9.8

$155.56

$3.33

14

 

2020 - typical

7.8

$97.22

$3.33

14

 

2020 - high efficiency

10.0

$150.00

$3.33

14

  Ground-Source Heat Pump

2000- typical

3.4

$167.50

$1.46

20

 

2000- high efficiency

4.0

$229.17

$1.46

20

 

2005- typical     

3.4

$166.67

$1.46

20

 

2005- high efficiency

4.3

$229.17

$1.46

20

 

2010 - typical

3.4

$166.67

$1.46

20

 

2010 - high efficiency

4.3

$208.33

$1.46

20

 

2020- typical

3.8

$166.67

$1.46

20

 

2020 -high  efficiency

4.5

$197.92

$1.46

20

  Electric Boiler

Current Standard    

0.98

$21.83

$0.14

21

  Packaged Electric

1995

0.93

$19.77

$3.49

18

  Natural Gas Furnace

Current Standard     

0.80

$9.11

$1.00

15

 

2000- high efficiency     

0.92

$14.82

$0.88

15

 

2010 - typical

0.81

$8.70

$0.96

15

  Natural Gas Boiler

Current Standard

0.80

$16.11

$0.55

25

 

2000 -  high efficiency

0.87

$33.82

$0.69

25

 

2005-  typical     

0.81

$17.87

$0.55

25

 

2005- high efficiency

0.90

$31.68

$0.67

25

  Natural Gas Heat Pump

2005- absortion

1.4

$173.61

$4.17

15

  Distillate Oil Furnace

Current Standard

0.81

$14.25

$1.00

15

 

2000

0.86

$23.46

$1.00

15

 

2010     

0.89

$22.69

$1.00

15

  Distillate Oil Boiler

Current Standard

0.83

$15.76

$0.13

20

 

2000- high efficiency

0.88

$18.83

$0.12

20

 

2005- typical

0.83

$15.76

$0.13

20

 

2005- high efficiency

0.88

$18.83

$0.12

20

1Equipment listed is for the New England Census division but is also representative of the technology data for the rest of the United States.
2Efficiency measurements vary by equipment type.  Electric air-source and natural gas heat pumps are rated for heating performance using the Heating Seasonal Performance Factor (HSPF); natural gas and distillate furnaces are based on Annual Fuel Utilization Efficiency; ground-source heat pumps are rated on coefficient of performance; and boilers are based on combustion efficiency.
3Capital and maintenance costs are given in 2001 dollars.                    
Source:  Energy Information Administration, “Technology Forecast Updates - Residential and Commercial Building Technologies - Reference Case”,  Arthur D. Little, Inc., Reference Number 8675309, October 2001.